Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Gut colonization by ESBL-producing Enterobacteriaceae (ESBL-PE) is widespread and is promoted by antibiotic exposure. Higher fecal abundance of ESBL-PE promotes the dissemination of the bacteria in the environment and is associated with increased risk of infection. Ceftriaxone and temocillin are commonly used antibiotics with a different activity on gut flora. Their impact on fecal abundance of ESBL-producing Enterobacteriaceae has not been studied. The objective of this study was to compare the propensity of ceftriaxone and temocillin to modify the abundance of ESBL-producing Escherichia coli in feces of colonized mice.
Mice received broad-spectrum antibiotics in order to disrupt their normal gut flora. A CTX-M-type ESBL-producing E. coli clinical isolate was then administered orally, leading to durable colonization. Thirty days later, mice received either temocillin or ceftriaxone with drinking water at a concentration simulating human intestinal exposure. Third-generation-cephalosporin resistant (3GCR) E. coli were enumerated in feces on selective medium before, 2 days and 10 days after the end of antibiotic exposure. The experiment was performed with two E. coli isolates with different temocillin minimum inhibitory concentrations.
Exposure to ceftriaxone induced an increase in the fecal abundance of 3GCR E. coli. In contrast, temocillin had no effect or transiently decreased the number of 3GCR E. coli. Results obtained with the two strains were similar.
Contrary to ceftriaxone, temocillin does not promote expansion of ESBL-producing E. coli in feces of colonized mice. Thus temocillin may be a therapeutic of choice when a temocillin-susceptible strain infection is suspected or proven to prevent the expansion of ESBL-PE in a previously colonized patient.
The global prevalence of extended-spectrum β-lactamase-producing Enterobacteriaceae (ESBL-PE) gut colonization is estimated to have increased by 5% every year between 1990 and 2015 [1]. Colonization is the first step leading to ESBL-PE infection, which carries a higher risk of treatment failure and mortality than infections due to non-ESBL producing bacteria [2,3]. The relative abundance (RA) of ESBL-PE is a predictor of ESBL infection [4], and could be positively correlated with the risk of dissemination to the environment [5]. One of the most important factors associated with a high ESBL-PE RA is a recent antibiotic exposure [6]. Few studies have evaluated the differential effect of various antibiotic exposure on the RA of ESBL-PE [7]. Antibiotics with an activity against anaerobes could have a greater effect on the expansion of antibiotic-resistant enterococci or Gram-negative bacteria [5]. In parallel, the intrinsic activity of the antibiotic may also influence the RA of ESBL-PE in feces provided that their intestinal concentration exceeds their minimum inhibitory concentrations (MIC) against these bacteria. Third-generation cephalosporins (3GC) such as ceftriaxone are recommended as first-line treatment for numerous infections such as severe pneumonia and urinary tract infections [8,9]. Their activity against anaerobes may promote the emergence of ESBL-PE in the gut of treated patients. On the contrary, temocillin is a ticarcillin analog with increased stability toward ESBL but devoid of activity against anaerobes and Gram-positive bacteria. It is marketed in Europe where it is frequently used for treatment of ESBL-PE complicated urinary tract infections [10]. This particular antimicrobial spectrum may confer to temocillin a low propensity to select ESBL-PE in colonized patients. Here, we used an animal model to compare the propensity of ceftriaxone and temocillin to modify the RA of ESBL-producing Escherichia coli in the feces of colonized mice. Mice received the antibiotics orally at a concentration reproducing the one observed in treated humans.
To reproduce in our murine model the conditions leading to expansion of antibiotic-resistant bacteria within the intestinal microbiota of patients treated with antibiotics, we determined the concentration of antibiotics in feces of treated patients by using the microbiological method described below [11]. With this experiment, we determined the optimal ceftriaxone and temocillin concentrations to be used in our mouse model to mimic concentrations in human feces in mice feces. The same assay was performed on human and murine fecal samples. For mice, feces were collected after 2, 3, and 4 days of antibiotic administration in drinking water. Fresh feces were weighed, resuspended in a saline solution, and centrifuged at 10,000 g for 10 min. The supernatant was filter sterilized using 4 mm disposable filter units with a cut-off of 0.2 μm (Millipore). Twenty, 10 and 5 μL of the supernatant were loaded onto paper disks which were deposited on Mueller-Hinton agar plates inoculated with testing strains highly susceptible to the antibiotics dosed. The testing strains were clinical isolates of Moraxella catarrhalis for temocillin and E. coli for ceftriaxone, with antibiotic MICs of 0.03 mg/L. Disks loaded with known amounts of temocillin or ceftriaxone were deposited on the same plates. Plates were incubated at 37°C for 24 hours and the concentration of each antibiotic in the supernatant was deduced from the inhibition zone diameter around the paper disks [12].
In a preceding study [13], we developed a model of stabilized gut colonization with ESBL-producing E. coli in six-week old female Swiss mice (Janvier Labs). Briefly, the normal flora was disrupted by oral administration of antibiotics and then, mice received a high inoculum of the strain of interest by oral gavage as described below. A period of thirty days was considered mandatory to stabilize the level of ESBL-producing E. coli as observed in human and in previous model [14]. This model was used in the present study with two E. coli clinical isolates: one isolate with a temocillin MIC of 1 mg/L (TEMO-S) and one isolate with a temocillin MIC of 16 mg/L (TEMO-R). We used clinical isolates from our lab collection instead of reference isolates to be able to more easily choose a temocillin-susceptible and a temocillin-resistant E. coli. As currently recommended in animal experimentation, we aimed limiting the number of mice as much as possible. Therefore, we used 33 mice (5 mice per experimental group in the temocillin resistant group and 6 in the temocillin susceptible group because of unexpected death in the first experimentation). A trial profile is provided in Fig 1. Normal gut flora was disrupted following administration of ceftriaxone (25 mg/kg/day), metronidazole (25 mg/kg/day) and vancomycin (50 mg/kg/day) by oral gavage once daily from day 1 to day 5 (the morning) [13]. Mice were randomly divided into two groups, and each group received one of the two ESBL-producing E. coli clinical isolates (5 x 10e9 CFU/mL) by oral gavage once daily on days 4, 5 and 8 (the afternoon). Thereafter, mice were left untreated for thirty days. Colonization by 3GCR E. coli was assessed regularly by culture of serial dilutions of feces resuspended in saline on a commercial selective chromogenic medium for isolation of 3GCR Gram-negative bacilli and species identification (CHROMID ESBL, bioMérieux, France). Additionally, total abundance of E. coli was evaluated by culture on a chromogenic medium allowing species identification (Brilliance UTI, Oxoid, UK). Plates were incubated for 48 h at 37°C under aerobic atmosphere.
Trial profile.
After gut flora disruption, mice are inoculated with the strain of 3GCR E. coli and left untreated for 30 days before exposure to temocillin, ceftriaxone or saline. Numbers represent days.
Thirty days after the end of the colonization procedure, mice were randomly divided into three groups of five mice. One group received temocillin and the other group received ceftriaxone for three days in drinking water. The remaining mice were left unexposed to antibiotic (control group with saline). During this period, drinking water with or without antibiotics was changed every day. As mice drank this water for their usual need, we used tap water and not sterile water. The mice included in the different groups had similar characteristics (Swiss type, 6-week old, 25±3g) and had been provided by the same company (Janvier Labs, feeding by industrial granules). Fresh feces were collected (the morning) two and ten days following the end of antibiotic exposure to enumerate 3GCR E. coli as previously described. Abundance of 3GCR E. coli was expressed as CFU/g of feces. The lower limit of detection was dependent on feces weight.
The protocol was ethically reviewed and approved by the Ethical Committee in Animal Testing, Pays de la Loire, France (AFAPIS 11747-2017101111159930v2). Mice were bred in cage by four or five. All animals in the same cage received the same antibiotic.
Results of bacterial counts are given as medians. Variations in bacterial counts are expressed as Δlog10 CFU/g of feces. Whenever no 3GCR bacteria could be detected, the lower limit of detection was used for all calculations. Statistical paired differences between treatment groups were assessed by 2-way ANOVA for repeated measures. We used the False Discovery Rate method to take into account the multiple comparisons.
Temocillin concentrations in feces of three patients treated for complicated urinary tract infection were 0.25, 0.7, and 1 mg/g of feces 3, 3, and 5 days after antibiotic initiation, respectively. It has been shown previously that mean concentration of ceftriaxone in feces of treated patients ranges between 0.15 and 0.26 mg/g [15].
Using the same microbiological method, we assessed the proportion of each antibiotic excreted in feces after oral ingestion in drinking water (bottles). Fecal concentration of the active form of both antibiotics was approximately 70% (median result of 20 measurements) of the concentration ingested with drinking water. This proportion remained stable over time (no difference between day 2, 3, and 4), with limited interindividual variations (interquartile range of the proportion 60–120%). Therefore, mice received ceftriaxone and temocillin in drinking water at a concentration of 250 and 650 mg/L, respectively, in subsequent experiments.
During the first thirty days, the fecal abundance of 3GC-resistant (3GCR) bacteria decreased, and then stabilized at a low level similar to the level observed in colonized humans. After the end of the colonization procedure, all mice colonized with TEMO-S and TEMO-R strains had detectable 3GCR E. coli in feces. For the TEMO-S strain, thirty days after the end of colonization procedure, the median density of 3GCR E. coli was 3.5 log10 CFU/g of feces (Fig 2A). After a three-day oral antibiotic challenge, no change in the density of 3GCR bacteria was observed in the control group (P-adjusted = 0.24 and 0.49 at day 2 and 10, respectively). In contrast, the density of 3GCR E. coli in feces of mice exposed to ceftriaxone increased by a median of 3.5 and 4.6 log10 CFU/g at day two and ten, respectively, in comparison with bacterial density observed at baseline (P-adjusted = 0.03 and 0.03). Exposure to temocillin led to a non-significant decrease in the density of 3GCR E. coli bacteria at day 2, in comparison to baseline (median Δlog10 = -1.50 log10 CFU/g, P-adjusted = 0.12). At day ten, no difference was observed in comparison with baseline (median Δlog10 = 0.51 log10 CFU/g, P = 0.55). Ceftriaxone increased the number of 3GCR E. coli in feces of exposed mice significantly more than temocillin at day 2 (P-adjusted < 0.001 and < 0.01 for day 2 and day 10, respectively).
Effect of ceftriaxone and temocillin on the fecal abundance of 3GCR E. coli in a mouse model.
Mice were colonized either with a temocillin-susceptible (A) or temocillin-resistant (B) CTX-M type ESBL-producing E. coli. Black horizontal bars represent medians of bacterial counts. Empty symbols represent the lower limit of detection in mice without detectable 3GCR E. coli.
The colonization procedure with TEMO-R led to a non-different fecal abundance of 3GCR E. coli to that observed with TEMO-S. One mouse in the ceftriaxone and one in the control group died during the colonization procedure. No difference in the number of 3GCR bacteria was observed in mice exposed to temocillin at two and ten days (Fig 2B). In contrast, ceftriaxone significantly increased the abundance of 3GCR E. coli at day two (median increase 2.97 log10 CFU/g of feces, P-adjusted < 0.01). No significant difference was observed at day ten (median variation +0.52 log10 CFU/g, P-adjusted = 0.08).
In this study, we assessed the impact of temocillin and ceftriaxone on the fecal abundance of 3GCR E. coli in a mouse model of ESBL-producing E. coli gut colonization. For this purpose, antibiotics were given orally in order to reproduce antibiotic concentrations observed in treated humans. Our results show that ceftriaxone leads to a major increase in the excretion of 3GCR E. coli after the end of antibiotic exposure, whereas temocillin does not. This may arise from two major differences between these two antibiotics. Contrary to ceftriaxone, temocillin lacks activity against anaerobes, and is active against most ESBL-producing E. coli. A vast literature supports the hypothesis that activity against anaerobes is a major determinant of the ability of an antibiotic to promote gut colonization by antibiotic-resistant bacteria [16,17]. The impact of antibiotic intrinsic activity on excretion of resistant bacteria has been less studied. In our study, a non-significant decrease in the number of the temocillin susceptible strain of 3GCR E. coli was observed during temocillin exposure (Δlog10 = -1.50 log10 CFU/g) suggesting that temocillin may have a direct effect on the resistant bacteria. Moreover, several reports show that carbapenems, despite their activity against anaerobes, decrease the fecal density of ESBL-producing bacteria or do not promote gut colonization [7,18], suggesting that antibiotics with activity against resistant bacteria could have a favorable profile. The differences between human and mouse gut microbiota may query the conclusions of our study. However, most conclusions of animal models assessing the impact of antibiotics on selection of resistant bacteria have been confirmed in human clinical studies [19]. Another limitation is the number of mice included in the protocol, but this choice was justified by a balance between the minimum number needed to provide significative results and the respect of ethic in animal experimentation.
Third-generation cephalosporins are recommended as first-line therapy for treatment of complicated urinary tract infections [20]. Our results, in line with others, suggest that prescription of these antibiotics promotes ESBL-selection in the gut of treated patients, which is the first step to infection and may be associated with an increased risk of transmission of resistant clones. Temocillin is active against most E. coli isolates responsible for urinary tract infections [21] and our study shows that it has minimal impact on the fecal abundance of ESBL-producing E. coli. Thus, in a context of growing ESBL burden, temocillin is an interesting option for empirical therapy of complicated urinary tract infections.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
Impact of ceftriaxone and temocillin on fecal abundance of extended-spectrum β-lactamase producing Escherichia coli in a mouse model
Facebook
Twitter
Linkedin
Whatsapp
